Oscar History

The Film Experience™ was created by亚博主页Nathaniel R.Gemini,Cinephile,Actressexual.All material herein is written and copyrighted by Nathaniel or a member ofour teamas noted.

Powered by Squarespace
Don't Miss This!
Comment Fun

What will & should win Best Comedy at the Emmys?

"IfVeepwins I won't complain.Really smart series that ended on a perfect note."-Lucky

"Russian Dollis probably the most affecting show I watched over the last year.It's brilliant and I love it - but as you say,its format and its tone is not at all friendly to it winning this.I"-ScottC

"Fleabag: Exhilarating,high wire stuff.Any episode is a masterclass of writing."-Arkaan

Keep TFE Strong

We're looking for500...no461 Patron Saints!If you read us daily,please be one.Your suscription dimes make an enormous difference.Consider...

I ♥ The Film Experience亚博主页



Directors ofFor Sama

Lulu Wang(The Farewell)
Ritesh Batra(Photograph)
Schmidt & Abrantes(Diamantino)
Wanuri Kahiu(Rafiki)
Jia Zhang-ke(Ash is Purest White)

What'cha Looking For?
« Life of Link| Main| "Outstanding Cast in a Comedy,Musical or Pleasantry"»
Dec 16 2012

Cross Country Critics Champs

To some extent I've lost my taste for covering the critics awards -- at least in depth -- since there are more each year and more which do that coy "nominations first!"thing to try to drum up publicity (it works since the web always needs content...even if the content is the same as the day before as so many of these awards prove!).I'm not trying to be a killjoy --I'm really not!-- but I guess I have anger issues with my fellow critics since they are all so willing to abandon anything they loved during the year once the year end Oscar movies hit.I challenge everyone to go back and read what critics wrote about Michael Fassbender whenPrometheuspremiered and then wonder why they can't be bothered with them now...even when they go so far as to announce nominations ?!?Oscar has a bias against genre performances but unfortunately many of the same media voices who complain about this share the same bias in their own year end honors!Someone will have to explain to me how Alan Arkin inArgoand Robert DeNiro inSilver Linings Playbookfor example are more exemplary examples of Great Film Acting than Fassy inPrometheus. I'd wait but I fear the wait would be longer than the running time of 25 historical epics combined  since who in their right mind would try and justify this verbally even if they votes say differently?

But look at me flying way off track!

So grumpy,me,I apologize!All that said,this year has had abitmore variety in critical winners than some recent years and I do some love reading awards lists.So let's hit four cities and one multi-city stop after the jump and see what they liked most this week...The results are not uninteresting.MORE

Detroit Film Critics Society
FilmSilver Linings Playbook
DirectorDavid O RussellSilver Linings Playbook
ActressJennifer Lawrence,Silver Linings Playbook
ActorDaniel Day Lewis,Lincoln
Supporting ActressAnne Hathaway,Les Misérables
Supporting ActorRobert DeNiro,Silver Linings Playbook
BreakthroughZoe Kazan,Ruby Sparks
ScreenplaySilver Linings Playbook
DocumentaryJiro Dreams of Sushi

Detroit shows a distinct fondness for their manic pixie dream girls (Zoe & Jennifer) and for all thingsSilver Linings.Wow,you'd think the film took place in Detroit rather than Philly.In Documentary they haven't gone for either of the Detroit docs that won raves this year (Detropiaor )

San Diego Film Critics
DirectorBen AffleckArgo
ActressMichelle Williams,Take This Waltz
ActorDaniel Day Lewis,Lincoln
Supporting ActressEmma Watson,The Perks of Being a Wallflower
Supporting ActorChristoph Waltz,Django Unchained
Original ScreenplayThe Master
Adapted ScreenplayArgo
Foreign FilmThe Kid With a Bike
DocumentaryThe Invisible War
CinematographyLife of Pi
Animated FilmParaNorman
Production DesignCloud Atlas
ScoreThe Master
EnsembleThe Perks of Being a Wallflower
Body of WorkGreig Fraser(cinematography: Zero Dark Thirty,Killing Them Softly,Snow White and the Huntsman)
Kyle Counts AwardDan Bennett,Festival Director of San Diego International Children's Film Festival

San Diego can be deliciously stubborn about bucking the trends -- especially in Supporting Actress where they tend to cite someone no one else is bothering to honor.And that citation is especially sweet since they also gaveThe Perks of Being a Wallflowertheir ensemble prize.But who saw theirArgofixation coming?In Body of Work they've made a truly great call.Frasier has been amazing since day one on short films and his career has justifiably skyrocketing postBright Star(2009) though weirdly people didn't honor that amazing film in cinematography in its year.

Oh but San Diego,you show much more independent thinking than many critics groups so what the hell with buying the lie that Christoph Waltz is a supporting player?It's not like you're an Oscar influencing behemoth who is sticking up for an unheralded performer.So have some integrity about it.He drives well over two hours of Django's narrative (it might more accurately be titledSchutlz Unchains Djangohe's so central to the film.Hell,Django only takes the movie away from Schultz once he has no other option!)

San Francisco Film Critics Circle
PictureThe Master
DirectorKathryn Bigelow,Zero Dark Thirty
ActressEmmanuelle Riva,Amour
ActorJoaquin Phoenix,The Master
Supporting ActressHelen Hunt,The Sessions
Supporting ActorTommy Lee Jones,Lincoln
DocumentaryThe Waiting Room
Foreign FilmAmour
Animated FilmParaNorman
Production DesignMoonrise Kingdom
CinematographyLife of Pi
Adapted ScreenplayLincoln
Original ScreenplayZero Dark Thirty
Marlon Riggs AwardPeter Nicks,The Waiting Room
Special CitationGirl Walk / All Day,a dance film

Ah,Helen Hunt.Well done.Figures that it would be sexually permissive San Francisco that finally wins her some statue (plaque?scroll?) to call her own.Not that she's a supporting actress but whatevs.Earlier in the year I thought that Joaquin Phoenix might give Daniel Day-Lewis a run for his Best Actor money with critics prizes but that was just me being stupid.Still,it's nice to see him pick up a thing or two during DDL's hardware collecting tour of the world.

Kansas City Film Critics
FilmThe Master
DirectorAng LeeLife of Pi
ActressJennifer Lawrence,Silver Linings Playbook
ActorDaniel Day-Lewis,Lincoln
Supporting ActressAnne Hathaway,Les Misérables
Supporting ActorPhilip Seymour Hoffman,The Master
Adapted ScreenplayArgo
Original ScreenplayThe Master
Foreign FilmAmour
Best Sci Fi Fantasy Horror FilmCabin in the Woods
Animated FilmFrankenweenie

Kansas is yet another example of interesting critical trend this year.Even when The Master wins Best Picture it fails to take Best Director for Paul Thomas Anderson.That's a bit strange for such an auteurist film,no?

Oh and Kansas.Hoffman is not a supporting actor.Sheesh!He's THE MASTER ofThe Master!Stop sucking up to Oscar campaigns.Get some stones.Quick would you still give him your prize if you put him in the right category?That would be interesting to know.

African American Film Critics Association
FilmZero Dark Thirty
Top Ten (Descending):Zero Dark Thirty,Argo,Lincoln,Middle of Nowhere,Life of Pi,Les Misérables,Django Unchained,Beasts of the Southern Wild,Moonrise Kingdom,andThink Like a Man
DirectorBen AffleckArgo
ActressEmayatzky CorinealdiMiddle of Nowhere
ActorDenzel Washington,Flight
Supporting ActressSally Field,Lincoln
Supporting ActorNate Parker,Arbitrage
ScreenplayMiddle of Nowhere
Foreign FilmThe Intouchables
Animated FilmRise of the Guardians
Documentary (tie)The House I Live InandVersailles 73: American Runway Revolution
Independent FilmMiddle of Nowhere
Breakthrough PerformanceQuvenzhané Wallis,Beasts of the Southern Wild
Use of MusicMiddle of Nowhere
Special AchievementCicely TysonandBilly Dee Williams

Did I tell you I finally sawMiddle of Nowhere?Loved!So sensitively written,directed and acted with interesting characters and well wrought central identity anxiety (why do people struggle to stay the same when time and circumstance march on?) I guess this means I have to look up Ava DuVernay's previous featureI Will Follow.

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (13)

Of all of the second tier critics groups,I look forward to San Diego and Chicago (and to a lesser extent,San Francisco) for their choices -- they seem to be the most iconoclastic and do not kowtow to herd thinking and AMPAS predictions.

December 16,2012 | Unregistered CommenterCraig

Guess this would be the only prize Think Like a Man collect throughout the whole award season?

December 17,2012 | Unregistered CommenterPJ

You absolutely need to look up I Will Follow.If I'm not mistaken,It's available on Netflix Instant.It's a truly stunning film and one of the more realistic portrayals of the grieving process I've seen committed to film.I'm eagerly awaiting Middle of Nowhere.

December 17,2012 | Unregistered CommenterW.J.

Nat,PTA won Best Director at the LAFCA,while Amour won Best Picture.Just FYI.....

December 17,2012 | Unregistered CommenterRichter Scale

"Hoffman is not a supporting actor.Sheesh!He's THE MASTER of The Master!"

Oh,but IS HE?(I agree he's a lead,though,obviously.)

December 17,2012 | Unregistered CommenterGuy Lodge

Guy -- well,yes.there's that reading ;)

December 17,2012 | Registered CommenterNATHANIEL R

The Master of "The Master"was Paul Thomas Anderson,so it's too bad that he's not getting recognized while his cast is,especially since the cast may have been the main problem with the movie.If Ryan Gosling or a young Daniel Day-Lewis had taken on Phoenix's part (Gosling can do ramped-up intensity without becoming completely offputting and deformed) and someone who was actually charismatic had taken on Hoffman's role,I might have tolerated the opacities of the movie and even begun to think of them as brilliant the way I did with "There Will Be Blood."(I won't even mention Amy Adams,whose face was stuck in that dreadful Actress Roundtable smirk.)

December 17,2012 | Unregistered CommenterOwen Walter

Hey Nathaniel...I totally agree with you about Fassy...honestly,before I saw Prometheus for the first time just a few weeks ago,I thought Fassy's performance was just hype...oh how I was wrong...awesomeness!And the movie as a whole has been unfairly maligned...great film...the surgical pod scene is classic.Looking forward to sequels.

The Argo boys I just don't get...the roles are not baity enough.

Shout out to Matthew McConaughey - he owned that role in Magic deserving as well.

December 17,2012 | Unregistered CommenterSo Sue

The Perks of Being a Wallflower mentions from San Diego make me SO FRIGGIN' HAPPY!

December 17,2012 | Unregistered Commenterdenny

I LOVE how you can see my city (National City!) in the San Diego mapquest-gy image!Also,congrats to Michelle Williams on your WIN!

December 17,2012 | Unregistered CommenterGeorge P.

I find it hilarious whenever American critics criticise the Oscars for not rewarding stuff they think is great filmmaking when now the glut of critics awards is just proving day after day that they're as guilty as the Academy.亚博主页

December 17,2012 | Unregistered CommenterGlenn

I firmly believe Amy Adams is the master of The Master.But what do I know.

December 18,2012 | Unregistered CommenterJacob D

Great call San Diego on the Ensemble prize.:)

December 18,2012 | Unregistered CommenterSanty.C

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Some HTML allowed: