Oscar History
Welcome

The Film Experience™ was created by纳撒尼尔 - [R。双子座,Cinephile,Actressexual。本文中的所有材料被写入并享有版权由纳撒尼尔或成员our team如指出。

评论Fun

“Yes No Maybe So?"THE LITTLE WOMEN TRAILER

“绝对YES!Queen Saoirse is coming for her Oscar!" -韦斯利

“你看,我明白了什么是Gerwig试图做的,但这是更没有不是“是”对我来说。多得多。“ -H

可能是吧我想我宁愿Gerwig对现代复述服食。-PAM

保持TFE强

我们正在寻找500...没有461 Patron Saints如果您每天看我们,请之一。你suscription角钱作出巨大的差异。Consider...

提前致谢

Interviews

导向器s of对于萨玛


最近
Lulu Wang(The Farewell)
里特什·巴特拉(Photograph)
Schmidt & Abrantes(Diamantino)
旺里·卡希(Rafiki)
贾樟柯(灰是最纯净的白色)

« Second Helpings. How Often Do You Have Them?|主要|Thoughts I Had... While Looking at the Foxcatcher Tease Poster »
Monday
Jun 三十 2014

1964年SD节目:艾格尼丝,莱拉,戴乃迭,格雷森和圣母院伊迪丝

看哪奥斯卡提名支持的1964年女演员:二富裕女家长与紧张关系,他们的孩子,一个绝望的寡妇谁也非常喜欢任何形式的关系,易怒教会组长看着你的一举一动,一个满身是汗的占有欲管家潜伏指日可待。

被提名人

Moorehead, Evans, Kedrova, Cooper, Hall

1964年的名单是在与61的平均年龄这个50岁的奥斯卡大赛还担任压轴三个持久的性格任何作用类别有史以来最高级的一个女演员谁好莱坞崇拜(库珀,埃文斯和穆尔黑德),但从未完全够在正确的时间交给他们的黄金的人。(事实上​​圣母院伊迪丝·埃文斯,谁没有出席颁奖典礼,入围最后一次,相当当之无愧的在灵媒but that nomination is sadly almost as forgotten as the confused woman she masterfully played.)

THIS MONTH'S PANELISTS

The actress梅兰妮·林斯圣诞快乐,罪孽天使)加入小组成员返回乔·里德,尼克·戴维斯,纳撒尼尔 - [RStinkyluluYou!我们还制表读者投票和报价从这些选票出现。

Without further ado,the main event...

1964
女配角的Smackdown

格拉迪斯·库珀为“希金斯夫人”中窈窕淑女
概要:A high society woman mediates the strained relationship between her difficult son and the flower girl he's been molding into a proper lady.
Stats:76年的历史。第三个提名。11分钟的屏幕上的时间(或运行时间的6%)。

梅兰妮·林斯:我不是音乐剧的粉丝,主要是因为我过敏,勉强打起精神,夸张的表演,那可怕的事情,人们放慢他们的讲话,直到他们最终放声歌唱。窈窕淑女拥有这一切丰富,但库珀是有罪的没有它的。她的美丽,她能够在同一时间传达温暖和删除,以及她提供她的线,一个有吸引力的脆度和效率,但性格有那么一点做,她只寄存器中,因为库珀是有点神奇..♥♥♥

乔·里德Guys,what与此提名?我看到窈窕淑女semi-recently and couldn't remember Cooper at all, but I figured that was me being distracted by Audrey Hepburn's lip-synching or the hats or something. Having watched it again, Idon't get it. It's not that Cooper's not good, but what is there of this role? It's like Ruby Dee in美国黑帮without the slapping scene. I ran to my trusty "Inside Oscar对于一些解释,但是我来到了空。对于this我们失去了对格伊斯·约翰斯Mary Poppins

Nathaniel:她赢得钦佩她的开场白“有什么令人不快的意外”,因为我们分享她与她的儿子屏幕坦率烦恼。爱触摸她显然只有一半听他喋喋不休,直至有兴趣要么惹恼了她。我会唱歌给她听:“你做到了!你做到了!我知道你可以做到这一点,的确你没有。”但她需要做的就是几乎没有所以...没有歌声。♥♥

Nick Davis:在这部电影的证据,库珀的年龄比莫什丘克更优雅。她似乎给人一种尖酸,但希金斯夫人的朴素的阅读,但像很多演员,她由她导演的遥远,stagebound相机阻碍。我们不会花太多时间陪她和几乎看不到她的时候,我们做,使得能够如果有挑战性的表现显得更加轻微。

StinkyLulu:Who'da咚是可信赖岁格拉迪斯将有助于(万物)温暖的欢迎激增丘克的奇怪临床治疗窈窕淑女?There’s no questioning Cooper’s capacity to cow the insufferable Rex Harrison, but tiny little Gladys and her nuanced little performance prove no match for Cukor’s steamrolling spectacle. I love that she’s there, but I can barely see her under that hat.♥♥

读者写宏“Serves the film well, adding subtle touches and spitting out those haughty lines. But still a boring coaster nomination" - John. (Reader average:♥♥

女演员收入11个❤s

DAME EDITH EVANS为“圣毛姆太太”在The Chalk Garden
概要:一位老妇担心她长长的疏远的女儿将返回拿孙女了。她雇佣了一个governness,以帮助控制不羁的少年
Stats:76年的历史。连续第二次提名(以下汤姆·琼斯)。32½分钟的显示时间(或运行时间31%)。

梅兰妮·林斯埃文斯给她性格高傲的不连贯的作品,大部分。这是迷人的,看到复杂的感情太圣毛姆有桂冠;她怎么是完全不能给予孩子任何边界的,即使她责备她。我爱她甩的是绝望question-几乎好斗的方式“你会陪在我身边,你会?” - 在德博拉·克尔。但她花了太多的电影断然吟诵的人,并在他们呆呆望着,直到它轮到她再次发言。♥♥♥

乔·里德这感觉就像是这种角色的人认为他们提名格拉迪斯·库珀。上层硬皮皇太后实况调查遍电影更复杂的人物,打我们所有的亲英派的按钮,诸如此类的事情。她最终没有钢材来匹配与狄波拉长青春科尔(!!!)是有点麻烦,肯定♥♥

Nathaniel:始祖玛吉·史密斯。她是铺设皇太后挑剔蓝图down,很少再次改变。不过,坦率地说,The Chalk Gardencould have used some of Smith’s inspired comic bite to make its outré elements more easily digestable. Evans is at her best when she’s revealing the petulant abandoned child within or pretending discourse when she’s all about decrees. But the singsong cadence of each line delivery only makes the film’s symbolism ‘butwhywon’t my garden grow?’ yet more dumbed down.♥♥

Nick Davis如果更多的人知道这部电影,我会说,“询问,Olivia, ask about!” to narcissists at parties, and my intimates could all chortle. So GIF-able, Edith! Otherwise, this feels like a Dench-in-Chocolatnod. I know she’s a Dame, but it’s hardly a peak role, and her emphasis on imperiousness clogs other possibilities in it. Moment to moment, her choices feel obvious.♥♥

StinkyLulu:埃文斯是各种各样的美味的多点的,做的事情ting and devouring Mrs. St. Maugham. In her delectation of language and delight in distraction, Evans reminds me that when I’m an old woman I, too, wish to wear purple velveteen. But in this movie-in-search-of-a-tone, Evans tips a touch too comedic, even in her generally effective emotive moments, thereby slackeningThe Chalk Garden的薄冲突权当它需要圣毛姆太太将它推高。♥♥

读者写宏She indicates with small gestures both her iron will and vulnerability which she can flash through in a single instant.“ - 乔尔(读者平均:♥♥♥

女演员收入14个❤s

GRAYSON HALL as "Judith Fellowes" in鬣蜥之夜
概要:The leader of a women's church group seeks revenge on her clergyman tour guide in Mexico when he's caught with her niece.
Stats:42年的历史。第一个也是唯一提名。的屏幕时间为24分钟(或运行时间19%)。

梅兰妮·林斯Hall has a swagger to her that is immensely cool, and her voice and face are both fantastic. But I felt like she set her instrument to "villain" and didn't modulate it at all. A few softer moments played like set-ups for an angry payoff; when she starts apologizing to her ward who she believes is lying in the next bed, I wished I was truly feeling her connection to the girl. Her rigidity is especially jarring next to Burton, who's delicious - lively, sweaty, present♥♥

乔·里德我应该说是多么困难是要注意,在这部电影除了艾娃·加德纳别人开始。但霍尔​​设法鞭打和爪她的方式来占领电影的一个小角落,肯定比德博拉·克尔更多的存在。霍尔的性格写在广招讨厌的,值得的赛璐珞衣橱值得后现代研究,但从未馆将扮演她的电影的判断,还是其与路障的叙述不耐烦,她表示♥♥♥♥

Nathaniel:她用自己的框架这么好。即使坐在她是如此生硬她直立。当她擤了顶那是字面的能量只能够逃脱掉那些大眼睛,生声带甚至认为不守规矩的头发。我希望她的场景不是这么写的重复,但祝福她对于意外软白“是什么,她说什么?”结尾。大多数演员会选择昏暗的自我意识,而是她只能模模糊糊要求求饶;不要让她采取措施!♥♥♥♥

Nick Davis:Hall is even more transfixing than the iguana, and almost more than Ava Gardner caressing shirtless houseboys in the moonlit surf. She’s the first coming of Grace Zabriskie. I’m impressed her presence didn’t get staler, given how the script keeps forcing her repeatedly through the same scene: approach neurotically, throw tantrum, swear revenge, repeat. Sadly, she short-changes the semi-repressed cravings that define the character.♥♥

StinkyLulu唉,可怜的费洛斯小姐,她只是这么高串成。并与在部分精致而又野性格雷森庄园吗?不难相信,在任何时刻,她的小脑袋实际上可能会爆开。虽然表征确实有费洛斯看似严重的慢性孤独比潜lesbionics阻碍更多,霍尔的性能猛拉到地面非相干但炽烈的感觉,迫使人物的每一步野深处。一个生动的奇迹。♥♥♥♥

读者写宏她既俗气的乐趣,而不是俗气的乐趣就够了。这是怎样的表现,需要更少的苏珊·海沃德和更艾格尼丝穆尔黑德。但随后,有什么表现呢?“ - 戈兰(读者平均:♥♥♥½

Actress earns 19½ ❤s

丽拉·柯卓娃as "Madame Hortense" in希腊左巴
概要:偏心法国寡妇套她的左巴,一个健壮的男人希腊,当他住在她的旅馆频繁结婚景点。
Stats:46年的历史。第一个也是唯一提名。33½分钟的显示时间(或运行时间24%)。

梅兰妮·林斯Kedrova扮演夫人霍滕斯作为一个女人谁这么希望嘲笑和失望的是,尽管她的哗众取宠是三心二意;她的喜悦有暗示她不相信它一个混乱的边缘。即使当她应该在一个浪漫的时刻来风靡起来,她焦急地点头,已经期待她的情人的故事的结尾,准备他离开之前,他甚至知道他想。她的肉体是通过艰苦的工作耗尽的女人;她占有一个精致女人的举止,而没有沉重的不断放手♥♥♥♥

乔·里德I can see why she won, as Kedrova plays an incredibly sympathetic character. She plays a rather sad creature, but does a decent job advancing a few moments where her inner life becomes the most interesting thing on the screen. It's nice to see, but there are limits to the sad-sympathetic-whore archetype. Hollywood tropes aside, Kedrova does strong work playing with the main narrative of the movie and, even better, running counter to it, occupying a corner of the story far more interesting than Zorba's logging schemes♥♥♥

Nathaniel:When she flashes back to her youth her performance gets so lyrical that you think she’ll burst into song. But she only dances awkwardly through an act she should have retired but can't let go of. Kedrova doesn’t always feel like she’s in the same movie as everyone else but hers is better, so, thank you. The film can’t decide whether to pity or ridicule this hotelier and maybe Lila feels the same? or is slyly covering her bases to play both sides:Lila目标为笑而薄皮夫人霍滕斯doesn’t like it when she hits the target.♥♥♥♥

Nick Davis:我反对这个角色,这迫使其解释er through serial stereotypes: the delusional coquette, the gaudy epicurean, the whimpering toddler in an aging courtesan’s body. Kedrova leans into some of these clichés, mugging with her face and body, limiting the impact of her sorry fate when it (inevitably) comes. But she works with what she’s got, livening up this weirdly self-serious travelogue picture.♥♥♥

StinkyLulu我们看到Kedrova的夫人霍滕斯的瞬间,我们知道灾难会来给她(因为它似乎所有的女人在这部影片中的世界)。然而Kedrova的夫人霍滕斯戴着她的面纱,其中的女演员利用了神秘的偷窥到人物的更深程度和复杂性的储备漏洞。Kedrova在角色巧妙地人性化工作证我们,什么时候破坏并最终参观,还在乎。♥♥♥

读者写宏我可以看到她为什么赢了。作用是花架子(但不是实质性的),她就得到发挥搞笑性感ditzy的老女人。但这部电影是属于男人“ -Tom. (Reader average:♥♥♥⅓

女演员收入20⅓❤s

AGNES MOORHEAD为“维尔玛Cruther”在Hush...Hush, Sweet Charlotte
概要:一个忠诚的管家试图让她(可能)杀人的雇主从世界隔绝。但为什么?
Stats:64 yrs old. Fourth nomination. 22½ minutes screen time (or 17% of running time).

梅兰妮·林斯It's great when people understand the campiness of the movie they're in and play accordingly (see: Gershon, Gina), but shouldn't the actor at least look like they're having fun? This performance feels like it must have been almost painful to execute. Moorehead spends almost the entire movie crouching, screeching, and aggressively popping her head around corners. I found myself warming to her in moments where her character is forced to move with some urgency and speak in a whisper, making me long for a weirder, quieter, more secretive Velma♥♥

乔·里德I almost feel like I shouldn't get a vote when it comes to Agnes because, as a gay man, I've been improperly campaigned to. How are people not dressing up as Velma for the Village Halloween Parade to this day? Those faces she pulls! That wild-eyed take on the loyal domestic, fermented in isolation in that big dark house. In eight out of ten movies, Moorehead would have been awfully over the top. Thankfully, she knew exactly what movie she was in♥♥♥♥♥

Nathaniel:So broadly cartoonish that it’s no surprise to learn her sitcom career took off this same year (Bewitched)。在辫子充满切断的手,月经礼服,假噩梦,和贝蒂·戴维斯A片,在现场被窃取几乎不需要任何剧烈的尝试。即使她蹑手蹑脚的办法就是让在上面应该有在混音雷鸣般的脚步。我没有家谱记载来证明这一点,但在美国路易斯安那州的Cruthers是在19世纪60年代北卡罗莱纳州的Ruby Thewes的直接后裔。♥♥

Nick Davis夏洛特should be delicious but instead it tars everyone involved, giving them too little (Astor) or goading them to vandalize their talents (Davis). De Havilland proves you can enjoy yourself without sacrificing dignity. Hopefully Moorehead at least had fun. She’s a kick to watch, appears to recognize what claptrap she’s in, and overacts as only a great actor could. But an Oscar, for cartooning?♥♥

StinkyLulu穆尔黑德的一个字符的这个纸板剪影全喉神韵是一个奇特的喜悦观看 - 在边缘actressing真正的炼金的奇迹。当然,我不知道这山的女人(没有一丝河口的)是如何来到这家路易斯安那州牧师住宅。但停止揭掉想的!看哪,魔法是穆尔黑德!视网,在她的手中,这部电影的shtickiest性能在某种程度上成为了淋漓尽致的人。♥♥♥♥

读者写宏穆尔黑德提供的商品的数额是多少,她的大屏幕上的绝唱。管理是一次有趣的,可怜和干扰。“ - 保罗(读者平均:♥♥♥⅓

Actress earns 18⅓ ❤s

THE SMACKDOWN GOES TO...丽拉·柯卓娃

In a very tight three way race between the widow, the Baptist, and the housekeeper... Madame Hortense just barely edges out her competition for one more ephemeral triumph to add to her nostalgic recollections. The voting this month was truly all over the place this time with no consensus among readers (where Grayson Hall took top honors but by the fractional slimmest of margins). Most of the panelists agree that the Academy should probably have looked a little further than this exact quintet. The most divisive performance came from Agnes Moorehead. Oscar trivia buffs should note that she is tied for second place with Amy Adams for Most Supporting Actress Nominations For Oscar Losers. (Thelma Ritter leads that pack with a 6/0 record.)

想要更多?
We recorded a podcast to expand on our thoughts!

谢谢大家出席!
If you enjoyed it, share it on facebook or twitter. We have another Smackdown related treat coming for you real soon, too. If you're new to the Smackdown we've revisited1941's catfights1952's pie-throwing brawl1968年的险恶sapphics1980's warm hugs2003's messy histrionics。此前在30 Smackdowns被托管@ StinkyLulu的旧网站

Further Reading?尼克替代选票你可以阅读更多20世纪60年代风味的文章在这里

什么是新一代的SD节目?
We've scheduled this whole summer in advance for your viewing pleasure. For July we'll be looking at 1973. So queue up this interesting quartet so that you can vote and play along:The Exorcist, Paper MoonAmerican GraffitiSummer Wishes Winter Dreams

打印“class=View Printer Friendly Version

Email“class=文章电邮给朋友

Reader Comments (52)

A-MAH-ZING。爱给大家,但有在这一个媚兰使它格外特别!

Such a weird group of performances.

2014年6月30日|意志^ h

好极了!我爱smackdowns。关闭比赛这个时候。我发现这个人在工作,现在我的同事想投下一次!

2014年6月30日|汤姆

That is one of the cutest Oscar speeches of all time. "Michael Cacoyannis,it is your fault, not mine!"
格雷森大厅显得精致。
非常感谢邀请我Nathaniel-这么好玩。XO

2014年6月30日|梅兰妮·林斯

我有它给Kedrova了。并再次提名她几年后的单枪匹马挽救希区柯克的肿胀“撕毁窗帘”(如搜索护照绝望的小女人)的几分钟。我可能已经离开格雷森·霍尔在'64搭配,但其他三个肯定会赞成玛丽·阿斯特(嘘......嘘),安·萨森(夫人在一个笼子里)和块杰西卡沃尔特上了一个新的弹出。她和吉恩·哈克曼使一个难忘的一对“莉莉丝”不幸的已婚的。

2014年6月30日|

好东西。我喜欢演戏阅读演员的起飞。谢谢,梅兰妮·林斯!

2014年6月30日|圣FranCinema

Thanks for this first round of comments, everyone!

Adding to the mix, and following up on the ever-reliable Canadian Ken,点击这里我大约还有谁可以而且应该被提名的想法。

2014年6月30日|Nick Davis

我真的很喜欢阅读本。爱的观点多么不同。

2014年6月30日|伤心的人

威尔 - 这是一个奇怪的群体。当你想到他们当年喜欢的电影,甚至陌生人。

梅兰妮 - 不用了,谢谢。所以,伟大的,有一个演员的POV一次。

肯 - 我不断听到安萨森但对于不同的画面。猜猜她在64有一个好年景。

尼克 - 爱你的交替。

2014年6月30日|NATHANIEL R

This one was fun, definitely.
并感谢肯&尼克拓宽范围。

如果你想在1964年我更困扰的 - 发酵在我自己的孤立 - 看到我TwitterExperiment,#64StinkyThoughtsOn1964。(I'm only up to #54, so you'll be seeing me wheeze through the last twitter bends in real time.)

But thanks, again, all -- this one was a HOOT.

2014年6月30日|StinkyLulu

男配角遇到作为SUPER WEIRD从现代视角刚从缺乏斯特林·海登的。突出地新书和概念古怪,完全伸直面临的执行,成为最恐怖的电影,最有趣的人物。(基于时间的类别,我猜奇爱博士当之无愧双NOM算什么了?除了这四个它有男配角(斯特林·海登),改编或治疗得分(当约翰尼迈步回家时略有上鼻子,但还是广泛有效的,“我们会再见面”的使用是片尾曲灵感的凄美,所以它是如何错过了有完全离奇的,除非有一个腐败的歌曲数量最低展出,使这个“音乐剧只能请”一类),B&W艺术指导(PERFECT现代禁区轰炸机通过猜测娱乐。忽略这样的事情对于尚未愈期的工作,为什么正常的人忽略了大多数高科技类),编辑。)

2014年6月30日|Volvagia

@Ken: I've seenLilith两次不记得沃尔特·哈克曼或。我要再次检查出来。有Lady in a Cage坐在这里,太。

2014年6月30日|Nick Davis

在双赢喜爱梅拉妮......她需要更多的电影 - 多屏时代...

2014年6月30日|Mark

I enjoyed all the insights into this weird gaggle of nominees.

如果我有我的方式格拉迪斯·库珀,丽拉·柯卓娃和Agnes穆尔黑德就不会在这里。替换格伊斯·约翰斯对Mary Poppins的,安吉拉·兰斯伯里在亲爱的心和我的鬣蜥之夜的选择。冠军艾娃·加德纳。我知道她会被认为是一个领先,但她的屏幕时间足够短,她也可能是支持和因为伯顿是这样一个强大的存在所有的女人似乎对身边卫星把他们都支持。

不能与戈兰同意虽然关于表演需要更少的苏珊·海沃德!我崇拜她,发现她的宏伟气派完全娱乐。真有那么几次,她可以消耗她的风光公平的份额,但什么大明星有没有呢?今天是她的生日过!我想我得去她庆祝电影的手表之一。

2014年6月30日|joel6

投票时,因为我写的纳撒尼尔的营销鬣蜥之夜提到“一个人 - 三个女人”,留下格雷森·霍尔的方程,但她认为她自己加德纳,克尔和里昂在旁边对伯顿的冲突。性能是固体如果有点预见性,缺少了她的一些多字符工作batshit品质的原始黑暗的阴影,a job she might not have taken had she won the Oscar. Who knows?

2014年6月30日|保罗·奥特洛

读来引人入胜,但即使毕竟这个我还没有足够的好奇,通过“左巴”坐。

I would say "Lady in a Cage" bests "Charlotte" in most regards, but I'm not sure about Sothern in particular there. I'm overdue for a rewatch.

此外,乔那种提到这一点 - 但* *什么是狄波拉克尔的交易吗?她在“鬣蜥”非常miscast,像她试镜霍尔的一部分,然后他们只是开槽她作为安慰的任何地方。

2014年6月30日|戴夫

什么参观德力梅拉尼L为寻求朋友的天涯!

2014年6月30日|Glen Risdon

Oh! For more cute/weird speechifying from Lila Kedrova, see her Tony acceptance for "Best Featured Actress in a Musical" (for the same role)。请点击HERE看到那一刻的视频。

2014年6月30日|StinkyLulu

精彩解说。所以高兴的是,SD节目又回来了!

I think that Yootha Joyce would have been a worthy winner for her brief but haunting performance in 'The Pumpkin Eater.'

2014年6月30日|麦克·M.

I wish I could share ALL the reader ballots but if you wrote one you should definitely put your commentary right here. Why let it go to waste?

2014年6月30日|NATHANIEL R

Looks like Agnes Moorhead must have rushed over to the Oscars directly after a busy day on the on set of "Bewitched."

2014年6月30日|jimmy

戴夫-- we recorded a podcast (coming soon) and we do go into Deborah Kerr a bit. I often struggle with her but I love her in From Here To Eternity and Black Narcissus and The Sundowner at least.

2014年6月30日|NATHANIEL R

LOVED阅读本!多谢你们。:)

2014年6月30日|泰勒

“I'm not a fan of musicals, mostly because I'm allergic to forced cheer, exaggerated performances, and that horrible thing where people slow their speech down until they eventually break into song."
This was beautifully written (close to what I think).

2014年6月30日|Me34

爱的意见本轮差距!希望我能都看到他们,但我只能如果不平去NOTI,这很有趣。我喜欢什么样的大厅用的字符做。该死的,艾娃·加德纳是真棒。我从来没有见过这么多戏剧性的肢体语言打开了一扇门(我咯咯地笑起来)。我也看到了窈窕淑女,但不能记住一个格拉迪斯·库珀的场景。

Invite Melanie back in the future :) And, Glen R, I agree about Melanie in Seeking a Friend... sooo good (and the film too, which I liked more than most, it seems). It's great to look at her IMDB page and see so many upcoming projects.

2014年6月30日|特拉维斯

我看到我的窈窕淑女与乔去年不记得库珀要么,所以我觉得说了很多。

我所看到的唯一的其他候选人是穆尔黑德,而是很多很多年前,所以我有一个更好的借口,不记得电影好。

2014年6月30日|格伦

我并不感到惊讶地看到,尼克不能让自己给三个以上的心中任何的这些表现时,他的替代建议包括格伊斯·约翰斯单调的特殊才能的兴起邪恶,玛吉·史密斯的短暂亮相在南瓜食者,安萨森,在伴郎的,否则很不错的合奏中的薄弱环节和艾娃·加德纳的有史以来表现最差的 - 给予或采取地震 - 在七天五月。这样的逆势理论只会证明奥斯卡权的,而毫无意义的目的。

不过,我很惊讶地看到,奇妙穆尔黑德小姐,谁是只给一个糟糕表现了她的过程中杰出的职业生涯 - 好了,二,如果我们指望她在龙子几分钟。- 显然设法骗过小组成员之一,即使她显然并没有打算在所有骗不了任何人。但至少她上当只有一个,原因 - 与乔 - StinkyLulu当然是在开玩笑。请注意,他怎么调用大多是没有幽默感的做法“一个奇特的喜悦看”,故意火腿作用意向和执行以及动画片“演绎得淋漓尽致的人”,“真正的炼金术在边缘actressing的奇迹”。而且,最重要的是,他曾经捣毁一个穆尔黑德上最伟大的表演,现在着重宣称“看哪的魔力,是穆尔黑德!”。好吧臭,我们已经得到了它,我们都哈哈大笑。但是,请不要让这个笑话走得太远,你想在表演冷笑接下来的时间,通过返回只是告诉我们你真的相信这样做。试想一下,如果你给了她四个心玩票可能导致性能我们都讨厌这么多居然赢得了SD节目...

并以不治疗,否则惊人艾格尼丝太严厉,我想补充平心而论一两件事:当1964年迄今最糟糕的演技点头(营女王亨利和这场可怕降序从云)相比,二,穆尔黑德在嘘......嘘,甜夏洛特突然在我看来是一个比较有价值的提名。

July 1, 2014 |威利

惊人的,一如既往。感谢所有小组成员,特别是主机,纳撒尼尔。

July 1, 2014 |詹姆斯Ť

Ah, I love the Smackdowns!

精彩采取一个(很棒很棒的)演员的角度看旁边的常客平时口齿伶俐,发人深省的评论。

同时,这里有我发至R先生的票

格拉迪斯·库珀- My Fair Lady - 1/5
伟大的女演员,没有什么表现。仅仅是一个those cases where someone gets nominated for maintaining an impeccable British accent into their 70s. And of course, popping up in a bloated Best Picture juggernaut.

伊迪丝·埃文斯 - 粉笔花园 - 2/5
I have a pulse and I therefore love Deborah Kerr. But one of my least favourite things about her films is the mandatory supporting character of Deborah Kerr's Walking Talking Sexual Repression Manifested. At least (the otherwise great) Dame Evans looks happy to be working.

格雷森·霍尔 - 鬣蜥2/5之夜
有什么地方都非常容易和一个小点点了约一个芡实音符她击破她曝光贵每一分钟。它既是太刺耳,而不是刺耳不够。她既俗气的乐趣,而不是俗气的乐趣就够了。这是怎样的表现,需要更少的苏珊·海沃德和更艾格尼丝穆尔黑德。但随后,有什么表现呢?

Lila Kedrova - Zorba the Greek - 2/5
A bonus point for sneaking in a couple of tiny notes of a recognisable human being amid the grotesquery. But dear Lord, such grotesquery! Though I blame Cacoyannis and his script more than I do Kedrova.

艾格尼丝穆尔黑德- Hush Hush Sweet Charlotte - 3/5
穆尔黑德饰演梅丽尔·斯特里普试镜艾琳乌尔诺斯的作用。这是一个应该做的正是当打卡住管家贝蒂·戴维斯在南方哥特式的歌舞伎。我想象她冲进爽朗的笑声在每服结束。

July 1, 2014 |goran

戈兰 - 正如我告诉你前面,我爱你写起坐。有趣,也是如此。尤其是德博拉克尔通过管线

July 1, 2014 |NATHANIEL R

由于纳撒尼尔提到红宝石Thewes,我们能不能得到Zee的奥斯卡胜利的梅兰妮的防守。可能是由于“媚兰的每月沉思”的博客上的第一部分。或独立,什么的,我很容易。:)

July 1, 2014 |YoYo

@Willy:你说得对,我们是一群乡巴佬的!感谢您帮助我们。

July 1, 2014 |Nick Davis

I'll start by saying that the actress that should have won this year wasn't among the nominees. Ava Gardner is simply great in The Night of the Iguana. Along with her achingly beautiful performance in Show Boat this is her best work. Another academy oversight.

格拉迪斯·库珀 - 我公平Lady-一个伟大的女演员,她很迷人,有趣,但这个是毫无疑问的窈窕淑女船他加禄语提名。她亲切的姿势和费力提供一个讽刺的方式增加了几个漂亮的小插曲的电影,但部分不使用超过她的天分一盎司。2个心。

伊迪丝·埃文斯 - 粉笔花园式的她似乎dottiness和顽强的毅力,她的方法是正道集团的专横贵妇人是被单独留下了打哈欠恐惧的盾牌。她表示与小手势两个她钢铁般的意志和漏洞,可她可以在一个瞬间通过Flash。4个心。

格雷森大厅,晚上Iguana-While艾娃的w要么k overshadows hers Grayson's finely etched performance of long buried feelings is quite impressive. Playing someone unlikable and making them even remotely sympathic is a hard thing to achieve but Hall manages it. Considering the time it was made and Williams built in self loathing of the character, Grayson makes her barely concealed lust for both Charlotte and Rev. Shannon palpable. Her near breakdown on the beach when Charlotte and Shannon are taking an innocent swim is tragic to behold because it's clear the woman herself doesn't understand why she's so disturbed. A showy part well played. 3 hearts

丽拉·柯卓娃 - 左巴在光栅片的希腊的膨胀性能。她注入了一些可爱的时刻,当安东尼·奎因得到她的方式,这是不幸的是罕见的。她让你喜欢和怜悯穷人霍滕斯夫人和她的表现非常好,但它并没有留在我身边的电影结束后,为别人做了。2个1/2心

阿格尼丝穆尔黑德 - 嘘......嘘,甜夏洛特 - 也许最有趣的运行,当然最大的性能。但是,最大的并不总是最好的,高品质作品的所有获得提名的有,不足为奇给出的女演员所涉及的人才。穆尔黑德的浮华文字工作更为显着,因为从端庄,魅力女星自己的角色它的这种偏离。她拿出很多东西从她的招数使维尔玛在影片中一个独特的存在的袋子从她饱经忧患的走到她飞快小气,但有见地的样子。唯一的人,通过从一开始就米里亚姆的蜂蜜假前见她的一笔巨大财富的电影。它仍然是一个宽泛的解释,非常愉快的,但那么直接。3个1/2心

所以代替艾娃·加德纳的实际上是能够拿起她这么当之无愧奖(我会评价她的表现分),我的选择是圣母院伊迪丝·埃文斯白垩花园。

July 1, 2014 |joel6

多么真棒一年。我爱库珀,让我避免了这个提名您的(尽管真正的)批评。我还没有看到鬣蜥或粉笔花园的夜晚,但与其他三场演出都值得在任何一年。

July 1, 2014 |索耶

“@Willy:你说得对,我们是一群乡巴佬的!“

One of you is.

不过请放心,尼克,我不会走那么远的给你打电话了一堆故意逆向的。然而,我觉得很告知五个心都放出来只有一次(然后为表现最差的),即使这个女配角阵容总体上是相当可观的(甚至已经提到的最差表现至少是令人愉快的)。因此,我认真想知道这是怎么回事在小组成员的心中。一切的厌恶,是不是Mary Poppins的?当然,但对于Smackdowners'的解释,嗯,约束可能是更简单:它总是这么多有趣的迪斯东西比给个好评吧,是不是?你肯定知道我在这里谈。

July 1, 2014 |威利

威利 - 可爱的,但如果有人在这里是既是故意和逆势而上,我觉得那个人实际上可能只是...

反正 - 完全享受这些写起坐和意见,并取得了一个诚实的誓言在今年夏天观看既甜美夏洛特和鬣蜥。展望1973年 - 一年中,我见过4/5最近相当!

July 1, 2014 |Mike in Canada

@Willy : Yes, Nick loves to diss movies and actors. That's why he took the time to mention his favorites in the supporting actress category from that year. Favorites which you, mostly, ...dissed
So, basically, the panelists' sin is that they don't agree with you.

July 1, 2014 |詹姆斯Ť

迈克 - 这两个电影都是超级有意思,即使你最终不会喜欢他们。他们观看和肯定讨论最有趣的。

July 1, 2014 |NATHANIEL R

是迈克,指出谁是永远毁了我的电影音乐既不行为也不是舞蹈享受的女人不会让你的任何朋友“在这里”。(虽然我们就可以了,我不知道梅兰妮·林斯的采取对Mary Poppins的是)是因为它可能不像别人,我知道,我并不热衷于成为我们的主,主人的特别钟爱。

詹姆斯·T,再次只为你:小组成员罪是他们普遍的做法, - 至少对我来说 - 似乎是相当热衷于嘲弄奥斯卡提名只是为了被奥斯卡提名。而且,他们不能把自己完全接受他们最喜欢这里只是证明我的观点的性能。

And that Nick took the time to mention his favorites in the supporting actress category from 1964 doesn't impress me that much, since it's my interpretation of his preferences that many of his favorites are his favorites simply because they were not among the Oscar nominees. Naturally, you don't have to agree with this reading.

July 1, 2014 |威利

@Willy:您的理论只是不加起来。几年你就不能爱任何提名。它发生。至少重:纳撒尼尔,乔和尼克我知道他们爱多场演出,电影等,奥斯卡爱了。他们都相信我,他们带来的是他们的意见,让(我们都是独一无二的,毕竟),教条的方式有利于从奥斯卡的口味距离不是一部分,无论主观性。
例如:尼克没有粉笔花园爱埃文斯,但他在灵媒崇拜她。

July 1, 2014 |詹姆斯Ť

I often wonder why I don't engage in the comments very much. I don't wonder for long.

July 1, 2014 |乔·里德

詹姆斯·T,就算我同意大多数小组成员不赞成从奥斯卡的口味的距离教条的方式 - 我不 - ,那么我仍然有我的问题,这个特殊的Smackdown。不是所有的,但是很多的评论让我最不必要的情节恶劣,居高临下。还有StinkyLulu的写起坐之一,我只是,如果他认真谈了不知道的特殊情况。最糟糕的是:没有一个贡献者能带给他或她自己给五个心霍尔或Kedrova?嗯,这一切我都觉得奇怪。但是你的里程可能会有所不同,当然。

Joe, your arrogant way of shooting the audience is in many ways the more "sophisticated" version of a 3rtful comment. People who can't stand criticism shouldn't go public with their opinions. Now go and watch Mary Poppins. You sure are in dire need of a spoonful of sugar.

我认为纳撒尼尔会问乔道歉。再说,我不知道。毕竟,我们知道谁乔伊的意思。

July 1, 2014 |威利

我需要看到夏季愿望,冬天的梦

July 1, 2014 |保罗·奥特洛

威利-These are OPINIONS not insults to someone's favorite pieces of work. None of the panel was moved enough by the work to give the full score, neither was I but it's still worthy. No need to get your knickers in a twist, which you obviously have and start condescendingly putting down what others think. You've made it extremely apparent you find no value in Mary Poppins, okay you're entitled to feel that way but by acting as if others liking it is somehow wrong, and being rude about it too boot!, you're basically doing what you are carping about the panel and others doing to work that you admire.

I though Edith Evans was best out of the group but that wasn't the consensus, oh well I'm not going to wail and gnash my teeth about it, I still enjoyed reading the opinions of others.

July 1, 2014 |joel6

@Goran:你有最喜欢的表演克尔?既然你听起来像她大部分的工作铁杆儿粉丝?

@Mike:我同意纳撒尼尔几个,这些电影都傻了眼和丰富的思考,即使他们没有完全成功。这可能是所有的人,除了真正的窈窕淑女,which doesn't feel all that slippery. Whatever you love or don't on first viewing will probably stay that way later, whereas the others are real shapeshifters, at least for me. I'd seen them all before and even though I'm still not wild about any of them, there's a lot to keep sorting through. Eager to hear what you'll think of those.

@Paul: Can't wait to watch that again. Is there any current equivalent to Woodward? Someone who makes astringency into a kind of signature style, and makes it that fascinating?

July 1, 2014 |Nick Davis

I am sorry to say I still haven't seen The Chalk Garden and only a portion of Zorba, which I had to turn off. The majority of comments about Cooper are spot-on--I love her, but she got in because she was on the right train. I adore Moorehead's performance, and it's interesting because this is a strange bird for Oscar, both in performance and movie genre. She deserved the nom for entertainment value alone, but there's something very affecting under that broadly stretched scowl. But my favorite if Hall, who is quietly relentless, and never overplays when it would be so easy. NOTI is so underrated. One of Burton's top two performances, and Ava Gardner should have gotten a Best Actress nomination for going to seed glamorously and with a devastating weariness.

July 1, 2014 |brookesboy

亲爱的威利,在华义感觉Mary Poppins的可能最好在这部预告片表示:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T5_0AGdFic

我想好好地爱所有的被提名人,但我没有。

对于我,five stars would be reserved for my favourite performances EVER. Like, Emily Watson gets five stars for Breaking The Waves. Joaquin Phoenix gets five stars for The Master.

July 1, 2014 |梅兰妮·林斯

乔尔,我的所谓居高临下的无礼从来没有来甚至远程接近了什么我扔在这个网站。和乔后 - 显然瞄准我说 - 突破由3rtful和结核病与何人所有的辱骂,我会简单地忽略你的幼稚讲座。因此,回到主题。

我的批评是小组成员的意见的不是。什么我批评的是,他们都 - 媚兰的例外 - (至少对我来说)显示出相当明显的“我知道更好”的心态。他们中有些人在相当长的时间这样做。因此,我认为是时候让他们停下来质疑他们(或多或少)玩世不恭的写作风格。

和公正的记录,当处于NAT或臭或乔可围绕女配角类别的每一个帖子滥用以这种或那种方式等带来了欢乐满人间,那我认为有权在评论也这样做,是。我会做,没有要求您的许可,乔尔。你不要求任何人的许可或者写你的凯瑟琳·赫本独白前。

But believe it or not, as long as neither Julie nor the children are in the frame (which is more often than you'd think), I do find value in Mary Poppins. But not in The Sound Of Music.

July 1, 2014 |威利

有趣的Smackdown,一如既往,我很高兴地看到丽拉·柯卓娃出现赢家。特别注意对新人梅拉尼:我很喜欢你的看法,以及你在惊人的“罪孽天使”。(你带来的东西“真实”到“在云端”)。

Nathaniel kindly suggested I add my own comments about the nominees (Thank you, Nathaniel.) Here they are:

格拉迪斯·库珀,窈窕淑女,(1heart). Did the Academy voters of 1964 struggle to pencil in a fifth nominee? Cooper looks elegant in her Cecil Beaton finery and provides simple, forthright support. But she misses some potential laughs. And, more to the point, this is an itty-bitty boutonniere of a performance.

伊迪丝·埃文斯,粉笔花园,(3个心)。伊迪丝·埃文斯几乎是唯一的(轻度)有趣的这个过于文雅,哑膜的元素(其中星级德博拉·克尔。作为一名前罪犯?),提供了坚实的支持和管理,以保持观众至少半昏迷状态。我希望她会一直驻扎的事情了,不过,因为这部电影非常需要有更多的活力。

格雷森馆,鬣蜥之夜(2个心)。她扮演一个萨福!随着苏里昂“不自然”的设计!谢天贝特西!由于这是1964年,这意味着霍尔醒目而有力的在她自己的权利,有义务包有足够的咆哮阵营邪恶的角色,BEFIT蝙蝠侠的克星,而她的性格必须忍受公众应有的惩罚和羞辱。而且,更有甚者,原来的源材料是由执笔。。。田纳西·威廉斯?

丽拉·柯卓娃,希腊左巴(5个心)。有特大人才品脱大小的表演,丽拉·柯卓娃创建一个感情脆弱的,荒谬的,贪婪的,但可爱的性格;她的夫人霍滕斯唤起布兰奇·杜波依斯,布兰奇Deveraux和健壮Oompa-Loompa。或者热闹的(她的舞蹈场景)和令人心碎的(她的最后一幕),Kedrova扮演这样的技能,魅力,信念和情感的作用,我们觉得对她的安东尼·昆的左巴做保护。人在这个类别的历史上最好的胜利。

艾格尼丝穆尔黑德,Hush . . . Hush, Sweet Charlotte (2 hearts). Moorehead’s role makes no sense—she seems to be playing the grimiest housekeeper in film history. Nevertheless, she manages some audience empathy in her final moments and tries to create a realistic, believable character. But when an actress is trapped in a film as sourly grotesque as this one, garishly directed by the subtle-as-a-truck Robert Aldrich, what can she do?

July 1, 2014 |Matt

马特 - “好色oompa-loompa”是我最喜欢霍滕斯夫人的描述EVER

July 1, 2014 |NATHANIEL R

Mine, too. Love all of these write-ups, in fact. "Batman nemesis" and "itty-bitty boutonniere" are also especially choice.

July 1, 2014 |Nick Davis

Post“class=发表新评论

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
作者Email (optional):
作者URL (optional):
Post: