奥斯卡历史
Welcome

The Film Experience™ was created by纳撒尼尔 - [R。Gemini, Cinephile, Actressexual. All material herein is written and copyrighted by Nathaniel or a member of我们的队伍as noted.

技术Squarespace
Don't Miss This!

LITTLE WOMEN- 评论

评论乐趣

年度最佳动物

"This约翰·威克dogs erasure will not stand" -萨提

"Diamantino令人高兴的是坚果。它的流媒体标准,你们大家。快去看看吧。” -W.J.

“我祝愿在蝾螈Frozen IIhad more to do." -Kin

Keep TFE Strong

We're looking for500。。。no461 Patron Saints!如果您每天看我们,请之一。Your suscription dimes make an enormous difference.Consider...

I ♥ The Film Experience

THANKS IN ADVANCE

面试

recent

导向器s(For Sama)
Lulu Wang(The Farewell)
里特什·巴特拉(Photograph)
施密特和阿布兰特什(迪亚曼蒂诺)
贾樟柯(Ash is Purest White)

What'cha寻找?
订阅
« Curio: Bad Dads in New York|Main|综述:碟中谍 - 无赖国家»
星期二
Aug 04 2015年

Yes No Maybe So: Stonewall

The director Roland Emmerich left his preferred world of dumb fun cheesy explosions behind briefly a few years back for the crass Shakespeare conspiracy theories ofAnonymous。但至少这对他不同的东西,我们赞扬拉伸。

他冒险了啊f action movie land again forStonewallwhich is about an explosion of a very different kind. Here's the poster and our Yes No Maybe So on the trailer is after the jump...

在石墙(其中,如果你不熟悉的纽约,是在格林威治村克里斯托弗街一间酒吧)骚乱不是exacty同性恋权利运动的诞生(有试图取得一些进展已经多次正式组),但它是宇宙大爆炸点燃所有来了以后。

So it's totally strange that there are so few movies about it. There's just one feature that I know of, also calledStonewall, a low budget indie that was released in 1996. But we're getting ahead of ourselves. Here's the trailer...

YES

  • Katey and Joe and I are planning to see this together at TIFF so for that forthcoming moment I am all yes.
  • This subject deserves multiple films just as much as any other human rights drama.
  • 该摄影和男生小艾。

NO

  • Is it too "pretty" with all those golden hues giving the rough and tumble actual story?
  • That moment with Danny (Jeremy Irvine) and the brick. Please don't tell me that you're making the masculine white boy the "hero" whoreallystarted the riots... this story and the riots that broke out have always been tied and credited to the drag community. Can't they even have that?

MAYBE SO

  • 第一个特征出演弗雷德里克·韦勒从谁冲进同性恋生活在大城市和吉列尔莫·迪亚兹为他的西班牙裔扮装皇后情人和Brendan Corbelis为他的其他情人,少“抛砖在早期活动家中西部的一个白人同性恋移植事情劝说。古怪这部新电影似乎是重复的是中央的三角关系的动态,即使这两部电影是虚构的呈现真实事件 - (在都市白领新手),乔纳森·莱斯·梅耶斯(更加谨慎活动家)和强尼比彻姆(西班牙扮装皇后) - 所以请不要告诉我什么时候有上百个可能,如果你的虚构的事情再次告诉我们再次得到完全相同的故事。

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

Email文章电邮给朋友

读者评论(26)

I'll definitely see it but agree completely with your MAYBE SO above. This seems like a remake of the 90s film.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter圣FranCinema

看起来真棒我。我倾向于是的,但我会是一个也许是这样,等待审查。美丽的拖车虽然。哎 - 塞纳博·西的困难时期是这样一个伟大的歌!

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterT骨

我越去想它 - 如果我猜这LGBT电影将于今年突围,我把我的钱这一个。而不是卡罗尔,Freeheld,丹麦姑娘,等拖车的开始似乎特别的历史意义/当代相关方向,奥斯卡哦,所以喜欢被拉动。

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterT骨

我越去想它 - 如果我猜这LGBT电影将于今年突围,我把我的钱这一个。而不是卡罗尔,Freeheld,丹麦姑娘,等拖车的开始似乎特别的历史意义/当代相关方向,奥斯卡哦,所以喜欢被拉动。

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterT骨

god, I'm so tired of straight/cis people in movies where LBGTQ are supposed to be front and center. pass, thank you.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter斯特拉

是。杰里米·欧文是太可爱了。因此,太可爱了。
NO. Everything you said.
可能是吧。这个预告片不是杰里米的可爱其他几乎一切。

所以,总体来说我是一个“也许是这样,”尽管在这种情况下,这个主题,而这个电影制片人,也许是这样的感觉了很多更接近“谁他妈知道?”

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterRoark

I should have guessed that this movie would put young, cute people front and center. This just makes me wish more people saw "Pride".

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterDave S.

The trailer looks good and what else do you expect from such a commercial director like Emmerich?! YES - I will pay for a movie in which gay men kick ass.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterJaragon

Couldn't we have a real director, like Gus van Sant, Tom Kalin or Todd Haynes?

Roland Emmerich SUCKS, dumb-action or not.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter卡尔·罗斯

Sigh. In full agreement with your NO and MAYBE SO. As soon as I saw the young man I rolled my eyes. I'm done with the White Savior trope. By most accounts, Stonewall is a story of drag and trans people of color. Period. Tell their stories or leave it the hell alone. In 2015 this is maddening.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterKBJr

艾默里奇这种材料看起来不舒服的配合。这似乎要出手太像一个声望照片。在这里我们希望它有一定的深度。真实的故事和战斗和时间应得的。

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterBrian Zitzelman

No (And thank you, KBJr.)

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter锯齿

我是一个号作为可爱的杰里米·欧文是,拖车使得它看起来像是石墙暴动的Abercrombiefication。

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter劳尔

Uh..... no! Sorry, it looks like a bad Oscar-bait attempt at a story that was far more interesting when there was another movie made 20 years ago, I think.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter史蒂芬

It should have been Verhoeven not Emmerich.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter佩吉苏

HARD NO.

Where is Marsha P. Johnson? Where is Sylvia Rivera? WHERE IS THE SHOT GLASS HEARD ROUND THE WORLD?

Like this feels like such an affront to the really amazing history that sparked the LGBT movement. And I know, I know we get into this discussion all the time, but this erasure of trans women of color's lives is just too dense/tone deaf for this day and age.

不是今天,撒旦,不是今天。

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter拉胡尔

I'll see it, but I'm not expecting the best. Sadly. And, yes, from the moment they announced the plot it sounded just like the 1996 film.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterGlenn Dunks

@DaveS并不感觉自豪得多bigger hit this year? Still so sad it didn't connect with a broader audience, was a fantastic film. This looks like the Hollywood bastardization of what that movie did so well. However, I'm still interested enough to see it and give it a chance.

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterChris James

"See, there's as many Stonewall stories as there's gay queens in New York, and that's a shit load of stories, baby. Everywhere you go in Manhattan, or America, or the entire damn world, you're gonna here some new legend. Well this is my legend honey, okay? My Stonewall legend."

hey, la miranda, somebody's ripped off your legend!

i felt like i was watching the disney channel remake of the '95 version

swapping bostonia's "don't push me, mary; i amin the mood" for some pretty boy throwing a brick?

哦,该死的

[但它激发了我观看原始无数次]

August 4, 2015 |Unregistered Commenterpar

。。。yeah, I've pretty much always been a YES for this, even if it's utter crap, but this trailer is troublesome for ALL the reasons you mention. At least the cast looks good, but really, if the pretty white boy casts the first stone (or brick) in the riots I will be PISSED.

August 5, 2015 |Unregistered Commenter丹尼

。。。。Did the writers/director do ANY research about who was actually involved in this movement or.....?

August 5, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterSean Diego

Alarmed, for many reasons stated above. I'll eventually see it for teaching purposes but I'm bowing out of TIFF screening.

August 5, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterNick Davis

Any GWM defending, soft-peddling this brutal erasure of trans POC, are revoked of all rights to complain about screen depictions of rich straight white men. When the shoe's on the other foot...

August 6, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterKatz

有人谁读了剧本,告诉我,它实际上是一个重拍。WTF?

August 6, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterDominique

看起来像54电影,但有消息

August 7, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterJamie

它是如此怪异看到乔恩·罗宾·巴茨(曲高和寡剧作家)和旁边列出的相互罗兰艾默里奇(低俗动作导演)。

August 7, 2015 |Unregistered CommenterAlex