Film Bitch History
Oscar History

The Film Experience™ was created byNathaniel R. Gemini, Cinephile, Actressexual. All material herein is written and copyrighted by Nathaniel or a member ofour teamas noted.

Powered by Squarespace
Don't Miss This!
Comment Fun

Emmy Nom Predictions

"I don't love Normal People, but if Hollywood or The Politician get nominated, I give up. They were probably the two worst shows I watched this year."-Jules

"Fingers crossed for Ben Mendelsohn in the Best Actor drama for The Outsider. He was AMAZING!" -Manuel

"I do not see Big Little Lies doing much in the noms." -RDF


Mira Sorvino(Hollywood)
Eliza Hittman(Never Rarely)
Cinematographer(The Irishman)
Songwriters(Frozen II)

Keep TFE Strong

We're looking for500... no457 Patron Saints!If you read us daily, please be one.Your suscription dimes make an enormous difference.Consider...

I ♥ The Film Experience


What'cha Looking For?
« Curious notes on the 344 films eligible in most Oscar categories|Main|Great Acting or Great Makeup? »
Dec 21 2019

Best Animated Feature Contenders: How to Train Your Dragon 3


Only time will tell which five movies are going to receive nominations forAPP亚博娱乐 今年1月,与abso但我可以告诉你这么多lute certainty: there are going to be a lot of sequels in the mix. Each of the four biggest American animation studios released a single film in 2019, and each one of those was a franchise entry. Disney had the blockbuster hitFrozen IIjust a month ago, and their corporate cousin Pixar released the slightly smaller hitToy Story 4over the summer. Illumination Entertainment had a rare flop withThe Secret Life of Pets 2. Before any of these, though, came my pick for the best major studio animated feature of the year, and a film we really haven't talked about very much at the Film Experience: DreamWorks Animation'sHow to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World, third and final film in a trilogy that started in 2010.

The film was greeted without much enthusiasm, whether from critics, fans of the series, or audiences more generally; this seems horribly unfair to me. While it is more than a little bit of a retread of 2014'sHow to Train Your Dragon 2in its plot and especially in its generic, forgettable villain (and one should never think "unforgettable" when watching a character played by F. Murray Abraham, but here we are), the emotional stuff is all new...

TheDragonfranchise has been, as I'm sure many of you know, a long-form metaphor for pet ownership, with the adorable dragon Toothless serving either as modern cinema's best animated cat or its best animated dog, depending on the film. Whichever it is, the artists have taken such enormous care to fill him up with personality through his wide-expressions and playful movements that, after three films, I'm very comfortably calling him my favorite example of computer-generated character animation.

But for as much as the unbearably sweet antics of Toothless are what gets families in the door, what the films have actually been about is the process of growing from adolescence to adulthood. The first movie is about being a frustrated, bored teenager; the second is about being a recent college grad, ready and scared to start taking on responsibilities as a fully-functioning member of society. This third movie is, I think, about hitting 30: you've figured everything out and life seems stable in a very satisfying way, just in time for everything to start changing. The film's hero, viking chief Hiccup (voiced, as ever, by Jay Baruchel), spends the entire movie trying to figure out how to keep the future from coming, and the arc of the movie is all about he learns to get over this. Writer-director Dean DeBlois is smart enough to know that his audience guessed in advance where all of this is going, and probably did so based solely on hearing that a third and finalHow to Train Your Dragonmovie was being made. So rather than treat the inevitable end-point of this story as a shocking emotional gut-punch, he spends the whole movie foreshadowing it and leaning into it. And this pays off in a really remarkable, low-key ending. This is not a movie that wants to make you cry, which frankly shocked me the first time I saw it. This is a movie that wants you to know thatit's going to be okay, and the level of restraint necessary to go for that message instead of handing us a tissue and demanding we weep makes this unusually nuanced and mature for what is still, ultimately, an adventure-comedy for children.

The story is the heart and soul of the thing, but it doesn't hurt matters that it's far and away the most technically accomplished film DreamWorks has ever made. There are the expected moments of obvious, knock-your-socks-off beauty: the hidden world of the title is a dazzling kaleidoscope, with rich primary colors shining from every corner of a massive space that the virtual camera floats through with the joyful weightlessness that has always characterized this franchise's flight sequences. But what's really impressive is the lighting. For the third time running, the film has brought on Roger Deakins to serve as consultant, and it sure looks like the work of one of the greatest living cinematographers, right from the start. The film opens during a setpiece in a thick fog bank, lit with torches and lamps that each have a different way of throwing illumination through the thick atmosphere. It almost feels like they're just showing off for the sake of it, except that it creates such an evocative mood, so cool and clammy you can almost feel the damp air and the humid flames.

This will be something that the film does a lot of. All of the excellent lighting, and the creation of virtual sets, are bent in the direction of making very physical tangible atmospheric places. It's not aiming for photorealism, likeToy Story 4; there's a distinct layer of magical otherworldliness to most of the film's visuals. But it's very present otherworldliness, if that follows. The film's locations are very easy tofeel, and that feeling is central to its character drama: it's about the coziness of places you don't want to leave behind, and being hyper-aware of every bit of what new places look and sound and smell like. The technique is impressive on its own right, but it matters most because of how well it supportsThe Hidden World's emotional journey. And those emotions, in turn, are what make this a terrific conclusion to one of the very best trilogies of the 21st Century.

More on the Animated Contenders
Frozen 2
This Magnificent Cake
Missing Link(Interview)
White Snake
Ne Zha
I Lost My Body

The 32 Eligible Films

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (5)

So would Deakins be eligible for a nomination here in cinematography if he only consulted? And how does an animated film manage to qualify for Best Cinematography?

December 21, 2019 |Unregistered CommenterCarl

Tim: Agreed. How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World as singular film? B+. How to Train Your Dragon, the trilogy? A+. This is basically the same thing LOTR pulled off: Three films that are substantially better than their component parts.

December 21, 2019 |Unregistered CommenterVolvagia

I was underwhelmed,but perhaps a second viewing is in order.

December 21, 2019 |Unregistered CommenterN8

I totally agree with Volvagia, the trilogy is superb. Even so the third one stands out on it's own as being the most beautiful, between, the lighting (as mentioned) the hair and features of each case member, and the emotional connection and investment we have to each one of them.

December 22, 2019 |Unregistered CommenterCelsiusPrime

If the winner has to be one of the big grossers then I hope it’s this one. The drama of the story is beautiful. However, I still think Toothless is too rubbery and toy-like for me.

December 25, 2019 |Unregistered CommenterGlenn Dunks

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Some HTML allowed: